If you’re considering the purchase of an electric callus remover, it’s important to understand the pros and cons associated with these devices. Consider the severity of your calluses, your time constraints and your comfort level with modern gadgets before making a final decision. A manual foot file may be the better choice if you prioritize affordability and precision.

Speed

Calluses can develop quickly, especially for runners whose feet are often exposed to friction and pressure. Using an electric callus remover can speed up the removal process, but it’s important to use one carefully to avoid accidentally cutting too deep and causing injury to healthy skin. Some people may benefit from a combination of approaches, including manual tools and products that soften and remove dead skin.

Among the best over-the-counter options is this foot soak from Tweezerman, which uses natural ingredients to soften hardened skin. The tea tree oil has antibacterial properties, while epsom salt reduces inflammation and soothes skin. While it won’t completely get rid of a callus on its own, the foot soak can help to prep the skin for faster removal with a pumice stone or foot file.

If you’re looking for a more hands-free option, this electric callus remover from Amope uses interchangeable grinding heads with varying intensities to buff away dead skin from your feet. The device is easy to use and has a safety feature that turns it off when the tool is used too aggressively, which can prevent injuries and irritation.

If you’d rather skip the machine altogether, a good pumice stone is a budget-friendly and effective alternative. This model from Dr. Scholl’s features a non-slip grip and an ergonomic handle to improve control. It also has a rough side that sloughs off calluses and a smoothing side to leave your feet feeling baby-soft.

Convenience

Unlike manual foot files, electric callus removers require minimal effort and offer a quick solution for smooth feet. Many models include adjustable speed settings and interchangeable roller heads to match skin type and severity. Some also include an LED screen to help you see how your feet are doing as they work. These features make them ideal for individuals who want to achieve smooth, healthy feet without putting in the time and effort required with manual tools.

While removing calluses is important for overall foot health, it should be done carefully. This is because excessive removal can result in painful sores and scabbing. A good callus remover should be gentle on the skin and exfoliate only the top layers of hardened skin. In addition, it should also be able to remove dead skin from the bottom of the foot.

If you’re looking for a convenient and effective tool to smooth your feet, check out this Emjoi electric callus remover. Its tiny rollers rotate 30 times a second to buff away calluses and rough patches in seconds. It also has a safety feature that stops the tool if it is used too forcefully. This is a great alternative to the classic pumice stone and can be easily stored in a shower or cabinet for use between foot treatments.

While a foot soak cannot remove calluses, it can help to soften them for easier removal with a foot file or pumice stone. One of the best over-the-counter options is this Dr. Scholl’s foot peel and exfoliating tool. It contains a mix of ingredients to exfoliate the skin and reduce calluses, including salicylic acid, glycolic acid, lactic acid, and urea. It’s also enriched with soothing epsom salt and tea tree oil.

Safety

For those seeking speed and convenience, an electric callus remover is a good option. It’s safe, but you must use it properly to avoid over-grinding or damaging the skin, which can lead to infection or take away healthy skin, says Boyce.

For a more hands-on approach to calluses, try a pumice stone or foot file, which is an inexpensive manual alternative that you can easily clean and sanitize. They’re also effective and less likely to irritate sensitive skin. A foot soak is another way to prep feet for buffing with a manual or electric tool, and many have soothing ingredients like epsom salt and tea tree oil.

You can also use a gel treatment that contains an exfoliating mix of skincare acids, like the one from Coddle & Cure that GQ tested. It doesn’t cut or rip at the dead skin, but gently dissolves it to leave your feet smooth and healthy.

If you’re unsure which product is right for you, ask your doctor for advice. Be sure to tell your doctor if you have a history of psoriasis, diabetes, or a circulation disorder; or if you have any other health issues, like heart disease, high blood pressure, or high cholesterol. Do not use on open wounds, irritated or sunburned skin, or any other unhealthy or damaged skin.

Cost

Some electric callus removers can be more expensive than manual foot files, and some require special cleaning or replacement heads or batteries. However, they can also be faster and more efficient than removing calluses manually.

For a more budget-friendly option, try this foot soak that’s packed with soothing ingredients like tea tree oil and epsom salt. Though it won’t instantly eliminate calluses, it will help soften skin and make a pumice stone or foot file more effective.

Ultimately, the best callus remover tool for you depends on your comfort level, time constraints and the severity of your calluses. If you have severe calluses or limited hand strength, an electric callus remover is the way to go, while for minor rough spots a manual foot file should suffice.